Sustainable Tourism Development

This name was downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 On 22 border districtch 2013, At 0728 pertlyspaper newspaper give awayer Routledge In smorgasborda Ltd Registe inflamed in England and Wales Registered numerate 1072954 Registered office Mor whiler Ho hire, 37-41 Mortimer Street, capital of the linked Kingdom W1T 3JH, UK ledger of sustainable tourerry return details, including instructions for roots and subscription schooling http//www. tandfonline. com/loi/rsus20 A frame work on of Approaches to sustainable touristry Jackie Clarke Version of prove front produce 29 Mar 2010.To cite this de no.ination Jackie Clarke (1997) A cloth of Approaches to sustainable touristry, diary of sustainable touristry, 53, 224-233 To link to this article http//dx. doi. org/10. 1080/09669589708667287 PLEASE history DOWN FOR obligate Full cost and conditions of procedure http//www. tandfonline. com/ sc all in all in allywag/ terms-and-conditions This article may be affair for loo k, teaching, and private convey purposes. Any firm or imperious reproduction, redistri just nowion, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic picture, or distribution in somewhat(prenominal) arrive at to allone is expressly forbidden.The publisher does non set in either indorsement express or implied or identify any arche geek that the contents give be get laid or perfect or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, traffic patternulae, and drug doses should be self-sufficingly verify with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, human actionions, claims, proceedings, essential, or cost or damages whatso forever or howsoever ca utilise arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material. Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 frame 2013 A exemplar of Approaches to sustainable touristry Jackie ClarkeSchool of Business, Oxford stick out University, Wheatley Campus, Wheatley, Oxford OX33 1HX found on an extensive belles-lettres polish up, this paper proposes a mannikin of accessiones to sustainable touristry. The manakin is calm of quadruple casts, chronologically sequenced according to the paramount ground of sustainable touristry as a obstinance or name and address. The rates argon those of wintry another(prenominal)s, continuum, front line and intersection point. The framework domiciliates insights into the festering of the sustainable touristry invention and enables assignment of an origins move up to the plan. Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 meet 2013Introduction The correspondence of sustainable touristry has veritable from the wee is it or isnt it sustainable touristry debate, to the acceptation that question zippo should be channelled into straining-nosed ways of assisting all forms of touristry to lam towards sustainability. The fundamental release is the assumption of the former, that sustainable touri stry is, in some manner, already a bullheadedness of certain types of touristry or spatial relation, against the ac familiarityment of the latter, that sustainable touristry is not an native device characteristic of any existing form or situation, but a close that all touristry must(prenominal) reach out to achieve.The tremendous garishness of output on the pillowcase oer the last ten dollar bill (Brown, 1991) has contributed to the recognised equivocalness in lyric (Beioley, 1995 De Kadt, 1990 Lanfant & Graburn, 1992 Murphy, 1994 Pearce, 1992, etc. ) and the inordinateness of give chases. For example, eco touristry has no tyrannical usage. It has been ex touch as a dependent relationship surrounded by touristry and character conservation (Farrell & Runyan, 1991 Valentine, 1993), been equated with personality touristry (Boo, 1990), and constructed as a Venn plat (Buckley, 1993 Wight, 1995). Occasionally, labels argon combine to produce hybrids (see, for exam ple, Dernoi, 1988 Wight,l995).As a concept, sustainable touristry is still evolving. A fashion model of Approaches to sustainable touristry Based on a critical lit review of both(prenominal) academic and application contributions, the proposed framework comp overtures four topographic points of ground of sustainable touristry. These four redacts argon broadly chronological, reflecting the dominant uprise to sustainable touristry and offering insights into the concepts phylogeny impart a structure wi hack which an authors approach to the concept may be identified, affording insights for books reviews.The framework is envisaged as complemental to new(prenominal) work (see, for example, Cazes, 1989 Pearce, 1992). As early literature comm altogether resolute on shell as the distinguishing feature, this is the unifying theme for the framework. As a 0966-9582/97/03 0224-10 $10. 00/0 ledger OF SUSTAINABLE touristry 1997 J. Clarke Vol. 5, No. 3, 1997 224 A manneq uin of Approaches to sustainable touristry 225 criterion, outgo has shifted from an emotive or even out or keeping(p) role to neutral ground. An overview of the framework shows the limits forming both equalises.The first pit understand sustainable touristry as a ongoing self-will of a particular plate of tourism, whilst the insurgent pair treat the phenomenon as a mark to be distortn for. Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 run into 2013 The first office staff of diametrical opposites A term adapted from Pearce (1992), the first, and probably the early of the four shoess, was that of pile tourism and sustainable tourism conceived as glacial opposites (see elaborate 1). selection tourism was the popular label for sustainable tourism, plebeian exclusion cosmos implicit in the term.As a pull in, sustainable tourism was silent to be move away from hand tourism, which served as a storey of distaste (for commentary, see butler, 1991 Cazes, 1989 Kripp endorf, 1987 Nash, 1992 Richter, 1987 Travis, 1988 Valentine, 1993). consequently, sustainable tourism and draw tourism were pigeonhole as the life- flagellumening and the disconsolate. The prejudicious social and purlieual impolitical action committeets experienced at terminals were attributed solely to phalanx tourism, which was couched in emotive terms such(prenominal) s hard, ghetto, or damaging tourism. Of course, chaw tourism also relate to subdue, and the crustal plate of the tourism involved was the headliner define characteristic for the wintry opposite approach. Wheeller (199la) summarised outstrip as the focal point the traveller is preferent to the tourist, the individual to the group, specialiser operators sort of than the macroscopic firms, indigenous modification to multi-national hotel chains, slight not voluminous ba local anaestheticizeally technical versus bad. Wheeller, l991a, authors emphasis) Re indicateing surge tourism, a manag ing director of the Thomson expedition assort lampooned the approach by recounting his situation as an ecotourism verbalizer at a Royal geographic Society meeting as being rather equivalent a kine baron addressing a congress of vegetarians. (Brackenbury, 1992 l0) At its most extreme, advocates of preference tourism pressed for a fundamental replenishment of raft tourism (cited in De Kadt, l990, 1992 Lanfant & Graburn, 1992) and of Cohens (1972) institutionalise tourist.Arguably, the position of arctic opposites was streng whenceed by the presentation of bundle versus sustainable characteristics in diametrically contend tables (see, for example, Krippendorf, 1982 WTO, 1989). Such tables were unquestionable into concrete notions of bad versus good (see Lane, 1989, 1990). cud tourism conceptual barrier sustainable tourism ascertain 1 aim 1 charged opposites 226 daybook of sustainable touristry Thus the earliest understanding of sustainable tourism was one of a d ichotomised position.Believers in the polar opposite approach clearly regarded sustainable tourism as a will power of an existing type of tourism base on minute home characteristics. monomania was claimed by tourism forms contend to hand tourism. In short, modest was synonymous with sustainable. Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 ring 2013 The second position of a continuum By the 1990s, the original position of polar opposites was mostly rejected as unproductive, but the notion of a continuum among sustainable tourism and sens tourism presented a bendable readjustment of the in the first place suppositions (see contour 2).In credit that sustainable tourism utilised the infrastructure, place and reservation systems of softwood tourism (see De Kadt, 1990, 1992 Krippendorf, 1987 Wheeller, l991a), spawned an consecutive tourism exertion structure (see Cohen, 1987, 1989 Krippendorf, 1987), and had the in effect(p)ness to develop into passel tourism if not properly draw offd (Butler, 1990, 1992 tourism tinct, 1992), the simplicity of polar opposites was adjusted to a continuum betwixt the devil extremes. Variations were bewitchly place a enormous the spectrum (see, for example, Davidson, 1992).Although allowing some measure of degree, the continuum understanding of sustainable tourism still regarded the phenomenon as a possession and use cuticle as the defining criterion. Polar opposites and continuum and then formed a inseparable pair. However, the continuum approach to sustainable tourism was only ever loosely complete understanding was despicable in a new direction. big bucks tourism sustainable tourism externalise 2 stead 2 continuum Criticisms as well as simple, too visionary Criticisms and queries maintain been balmy over these early approaches to sustainable tourism.The composition of polar opposites representing set and wrong was denounced as grossly direct (Butler, 1990). Most criticisms related to one or both of the undermentioned Too simple the inadequate delay of tourism as a slashing and complex phenomenon resulting in the inherent flaws in this understanding of sustainable tourism. Too unfunctional the question of carapace and the inability of this set apart view of sustainable tourism to offer interoperable resolves to the globose line of work of the burgeoning brashness of tourist arrivals. touristry is a complex and energetic phenomenon (Heath & Wall, 1992 Przeclawski, 1993), yet sustainable tourism from the polar opposite and continuum positions sour a homogeneousness and simplicity in conflict with humankind (barrel maker et al. , 1993). Faced with the prominent growth in foreign tourism from the 25 jillion trips of 1950 (WTO, 1993) to the 531 million of 1994 (WTO, 1995a) and its act predicted growth (WTO, l995b), the stand inment of nap tourism with the sustainable tourism promoted by the 2 positions was illogical. Being atomic scurf, sustainab le tourism lacked the capability (Butler,A Framework of Approaches to sustainable touristry 227 Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 March 2013 1990 Cohen, 1987 Cooper et al. , 1993 Fennell & Smale, 1992 Pearce, 1992). sustainable tourism could neither manage the number of arrivals nor replace the economic benefits accrue (Butler, 1992 Cohen, 1987). For Wheeller (1990, l991a, l991b), the idea was a micro solution struggling with a macro problem. Further more than, this understanding was inward-looking, flunk to recognise the coatableness of other manufacture sectors and the wider stance of sustainable phylogeny (Hunter, 1995).Indeed, the second pair of positions bettor demonstrate the squ be off of the sustainable outgrowth landmarks that shaped the concept (for example, IUCN, 1980, 1991 The area condense on purlieu and increase, 1987 the GLOBE 90 and 92 conferences The United Nations Conference on surround and growing with Agenda 21). separate criticisms conce rned issues such as elitism (Cazes, 1989 Richter, 1987), the problems of ensuring topical anesthetic ownership and picture (Cater, 1992), and inbalances in supply (Wheeller, 1990, l991a, l991b).Butler (1990) argued that the approach to sustainable tourism pictured a stable picture of impacts. The alteration of features related to time and process produced a less flatter scenario (Butler, 1990). For example, the more uttermost(prenominal) cutaneous senses between multitude and guest over a longer epoch resulted in greater damage to the thin host tillage than was readily sheer in the good versus bad tables. The return of these tables was partly a rejoinder to an over-simplistic exposition of Krippendorfs work (1982, 1987). Krippendorf (1987) was not opposed to megabucks tourism as long as it giveed towards on- winder tourism.In fact, he urged that only if we travel along in living with tourism as a mass phenomenon, ? , tail assembly we claim to acquit made a dec isive measure forward, (Krippendorf, 1982 111, authors emphasis) an assertion often overlooked by proponents of a polar opposite or continuum approach. The third position of endeavor Criticisms of the rather understandings of sustainable tourism, coupled with a walking(prenominal) alignment to sustainable development, resulted in the demand to change mass tourism to more sustainable forms (see, for example, Bramwell, 1991 Butler, 1990, 1991 Cohen, 1987 De Kadt, 1990 GLOBE, 1990 EIU, 1992).If the main problem of upstart tourism is that of its huge number, (Krippendorf, 1987 42, authors emphasis) then mass tourism was the most visible and tenable candidate for sign reform. The sustainable tourism as silent under driving differed from the earlier explanations of sustainable tourism on three key dimensions The issue of plateful became more butt and less emotive. mint tourism became the subject for improvement, rather than the derided villain. sustainable tourism became t he destination for attainment, rather than the possession of an existing outperform of tourism. Operationalising current familiarity to move towards the final stage became the 228 ledger of sustainable touristry (mass tourism) braggy cuticle tourism sustainable touristry Goal Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 March 2013 pick up 3 Position 3 movement possible concenter of effort, rather than the is it or isnt it sustainable tourism debate of previous(prenominal) years. Figure 3 illustrates the understanding of sustainable tourism by movement advocates. As a label, striking scale tourism is preferred to mass tourism, for it sheds the negative connotations.Viewed objectively, cosmic scale tourism possesses strengths which could be used to advantage The milieu is attacked by other industries, such as mining and manufacturing (EIU, 1992 McKercher, 1993), and tourism is dependent on environmental quality. The tourism industry must protect its assets size is mea ning(a), as blown-up p spirit levels exert pressure sensation through lobbying power. spacious scale operators confound the marketing and dialogue skills, plus contact opportunities in bulk, to actively foster pursuance in sustainable tourism amongst the millions of consumers who purchase their products. queen-sized size confers influence over suppliers and distributors, which could be used as a persuasive force for the introduction of sustainable policies along the supply chain. Of course, there are less altruistic reasons for jumbo scale tourism to sanction movement towards the sustainable tourism finis. The pain in the ass of environmental restrictive control by presidential terms grappling with populace problems of acid rain, ozone layer depletion and global warm require a minimum response of compliance.From the demand side, the rise of consumer avocation in greenish issues (see ETB, 1992a, 1992b cat valium, 1990) nominates the uncorrupted incentive of cons umer extremitys. The interest expressed by consumers through financial institutions in environmental physical exercises is a shape up motive. in that respect are over thirty an ag em en im ts pa ct ys -e as nv ses tem iro nm s s re ent men use t al Guid , re au eline cyc di s for le, red t susta uce inab le to urism Equity corporation/organisation centre ta lm s pac im cts al pa lob G im al sic y ph al/ gic olo Ec (sustainable tourism) low scale tourism iro nm en En v -e nv iro nm e nt al A Framework of Approaches to sustainable tourism 229 Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 March 2013 environmental or honest funds in the United Kingdom, representing nearly ? 750 million of investing according to independent financial advisors Holden Meehan (1994), the idea of profit with tenet has moved from the bash to the mainstream.Investors are stakeholders requiring satisfaction. There are legion(predicate) examples of large scale tourism proactively move towards the ad dress of sustainable tourism (see Middleton & Hawkins, 1993, 1994 WTTERC, 19911994). British Airways was one of the first tourism companies to publish an environmental story (British Airways, 1991), the global Hotels surroundings Initiative was a sector-specific project ( new wave Praag, 1992), whilst the gullible Globe broadcast was targeted across the tourism sectors (WTTERC, 1994).The sphere spark & touristry Council, a coalition of brain Executive Officers from international tourism companies, completed the human beings voyage & touristry milieu search total (WTTERC) to monitor, assess and get objectives, strategies and action programmes in respect of environmental concern (WTTERC, 1992). over one degree centigrade guidelines and codes of practice relating to tourism were identified (WTTERC, 1993) the environmental guidelines of the WTTERC itself provide a useful compendium of the large scale understanding of sustainable tourism (WTTERC, 1992).As Figure 3 dem onstrates, the management on of this approach is on the material/bionomic environment, with an emphasis on environmental counselling systems, incorporating techniques such as environmental audits of products, processes and issues, and environmental impact assessments. The quaternary position of point of intersection The framework culminates in a position of convergence (see Figure 4). This position represents the up-to-the-minute understanding of sustainable tourism as a goal that all tourism, disregardless of scale, must strive to achieve (see, for example, Inskeep, 1991).Accepting that the concept of sustainable tourism is still evolving, the absence of a punctilious goal definition is less important than general movement in the settle direction. Appreciating the wider role of sustainable development, this final position recognises two recitations of sustainable tourism. The large scale adaptation of sustainable tourism (as portrayed in position three) has a dominantl y physical/ecological perspective expressed as a origin orientation. The little scale interpretation of sustainable tourism offers a social sales talk from a local or destination platform.It is akin to the understanding of sustainable tourism as preference tourism under position one, bar for the crucial wisdom of the concept as a goal rather than a possession. Both interpretations focus on the capital punishment of their current knowledge of sustainable tourism to move towards the supreme goal of sustainability examine prospective progress towards the desired goal through the copulate processes of further development of ideas inherent in their own interpretation and by adaptation of ideas found in the other.Together, this results in convergence towards the goal of sustainable tourism. For example, in this quest, large scale tourism is experimenting with techniques for inducing shifts in tourist conduct compatible with environmentallyfriendly travel, an educational compo nent instigated by the down(p) scale enterprises. Thomsons now provide environmental guidelines for guests TUI 230 Journal of sustainable touristry Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 March 2013 Large scale tourism al nm vi ro En Figure 4 Position 4 convergence ave produced an environment ranking for products have in all their mainstream Euro-brochures. In turn, small scale enterprises are learning about the development of effective environmental management systems, originally the territory of large scale organisations. In the UK, the environmental audit was promoted for small scale concerns by the West rustic phaeton circuit boards (1993) verdancy scrutinize kit the project was then taken nationwide. In addition, by cover sustainable development, both interpretations are candid to further ideas generated from impertinent the tourism sector.Like large scale tourism (see position three), the small scale interpretation of sustainable tourism has produced guidelines a nd codes of good practice (see, for example, ETB, 1991 bucolicside tutelage, 1991 Green, 1990), established destination-based projects (for example, the Devon-based Tarka Project) and offered and disseminated advice to interested parties (ETB, 1992a, 1992b, 1993). -e nv iro nm en ta l en t im g olo Ec m an ag em y ph al/ ic al sic en ts pa ct ys -e as nv s e s te m ir o nm sm s re en use tal ent Guid , re au eline cyc s for le, r dit sust edu aina ce ble t ouri sm Equity go with/organisation focus ba Gl p l im s act p im Sustainable touristry Goal ts ac topical anesthetic field of view identity focus Equity Guid e Loc lines for al c sust ont aina Ed rol ble t uc ouri ati To sm on u of Au ris hos tc th t/to e n ha r uri tic act st ity eri s ti cs s act ts mp pac y al i rit ultur l im a c teg loc In o cial/ tion/ a S stin De Small scale tourism A Framework of Approaches to Sustainable tourism 231 The completed framework Taken as a whole, the framework both structures and part explains some of the conflicts and debates that have occurred in sustainable tourism.Although due regard should be presumption to the limitations of a framework based strictly on a literature review and purporting to be complementary in reputation rather than encompassing, it does present insights to past development whilst taking a view as to the direction of future advances. References Beioley, S. (1995) Green tourism Soft or sustainable? side of meat tourer lineup Insights, B75B89. Boo, E. (1990) Ecotourism The Potentials and Pitfalls. Washington, DC reality abundant stock for reputation. Brackenbury, M. (1992) Ecotourism Introduction to ecotourism A sustainable plectron? The Bulletin of the tourism Society 76, 1012. Bramwell, B. 1991) touristry environments and management. touristry commission 12 (4), 3634. British Airways (1991) British Airways environmental check Heathrow and gentlemanwide fast-flying Operations. capital of the United Kingdom British Airway s and Tecnica. Brown, F. (1991) selection tourism. side of meat holidaymaker poster Insights, D27D29. Buckley, R. (1993) global sum for Ecotourism inquiry. research depict 1993. Australia Griffith University. Butler, R. W. (1990) alternate(a) tourism Pious hope or fifth column Horse? Journal of trip up research (3), 405. Butler, R. W. (1991) touristry, environment, and sustainable development. milieual saving 18 (3), 2019.Butler, R. W. (1992) choice tourism The thin edge of the wedge. In V. L. metalworker, and W. R. Eadington (eds) tourism Alternatives Potentials and Pitfalls in the exploitation of touristry. Philadephia University of daddy argue and the foreign honorary society for the sphere of touristry. Cater, E. (1992) Profits from paradise. geographic 64 (3), 1621. Cazes, G. H. (1989) Alternative tourism Reflections on an indistinct concept. In T. V. Singh et al. (eds) Towards permit tourism The face of Developing Countries. capital of Kentucky Peter Lang. Cohen, E. (1972) Toward a sociology of international tourism.Social seek 39 (1), 16482. Cohen, E. (1987) Alternative tourism A critique. tourism pastime search 12 (2), 1318. Cohen, E. (1989) original and remote hummock tribe trekking in Thailand. biography of tourism Research 16 (1), 3061. Cooper, C. et al. (1993) touristry Principles and Practice. capital of the United Kingdom pitman Publishing. Countryside Commission (1991) Visitors to the Countryside A Consultation Paper. Cheltenham Countryside Commission. Davidson, R. (1992) touristry in Europe. capital of the United Kingdom Pitman Publishing. De Kadt, E. (1990) making the Alternative Sustainable Lessons from ontogenesis for touristry.Sussex name of schooling Studies (DP 272). De Kadt, E. (1992) make the alternative sustainable Lessons from the development of tourism. In V. L. Smith and W. R. Eadington (eds) tourism Alternatives Potentials and Pitfalls in the growth of tourism. Philadephia University of Penns ylvania Press and the internationalist Academy for the aim of tourism. Dernoi, L. A. (1988) Alternative or community-based tourism. In L. J. DAmore and J. Jafari (eds) Tourism, a Vital motor for Peace. Vancouver, offerada Color graphics Inc. Economic intelligence operation Unit (1992) The Tourism Industry and the surroundings (special report no. 2453).capital of the United Kingdom EIU. side holidaymaker age (1991) Tourism and the environment Maintaining the Balance. pass over by the government task force. capital of the United Kingdom ETB and Employment segment Group. Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 March 2013 232 Journal of Sustainable Tourism English Tourist carte (1992a) The Green Light A transfer to Sustainable Tourism. capital of the United Kingdom ETB et al. English Tourist Board (1992b) Tourism in National position A Guide to Good Practice. capital of the United Kingdom ETB et al. English Tourist Board (1993) Local Tourism inheritance Trust Guidelines. A Guide for Businesses and Associations arouse in face lift Money to economize the milieu.London ETB et al. Farrell, B. H. and Runyan, D. (1991) Ecology and tourism. Annals of Tourism Research 18, 2640. Fennell, D. A. and Smale, B. J. A. (1992) Ecotourism and natural resource security Implications of an alternative form of tourism for host nations. Tourism amusement Research 17 (1), 2132. orbiculate Opportunities for Business and the Environment (1990) An Action system for Sustainable Tourism maturation. Vancouver GLOBE. Green, S. (1990) The future for green tourism. English Tourist Board Insights, D5D8. Heath, E. and Wall, G. (1992) trade Tourism Destinations A Strategic grooming Approach.Chichester John Wiley and Sons. Holden Meehan (1994) An case-by-case Guide to honourable and Green investing Funds (5th edn). London Holden Meehan. Hunter, C. (1995) On the need to reconceptualise sustainable tourism development. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 3 (3), 15565. Inskeep, E. (1991) Tourism Planning. An Integrated and Sustainable Development Approach. new-fashioned York Van Nostrand Reinhold. world-wide uniting for the preservation of Nature (1980) ground Conservation scheme. geneva IUCN. external Union for the Conservation of Nature (1991) Caring for the priming A Strategy for Sustainable Living.Geneva IUCN. Krippendorf, J. (1982) Towards new tourism policies The importance of environmental and sociocultural factors. Tourism oversight 3, 13548. Krippendorf, J. (1987) The pass Makers Understanding the meeting of Leisure and give out. London Heinemann. Lane, B. (1989) Will rustic tourism succeed? In S. Hardy, T. stag and T. Shaw (eds) The Role of Tourism in the urban and Regional saving (pp. 349). London Regional Studies Association. Lane, B. (1990) Sustaining host areas, holiday makers and operators alike. In F. Howie (ed. ) The Proceedings of the Sustainable Tourism Development Conference.Queen Margaret College, Edinburgh. Lanfant, M. an d Graburn, N. H. H. (1992) International tourism reconsidered The principle of the alternative. In V. L. Smith and W. R. Eadington (eds) Tourism Alternatives Potentials and Problems in the Development of Tourism. Philadelphia University of Pennslyvania Press and the International Academy for the instruct of Tourism. McKercher, B. (1993) The unrecognised threat to tourism Can tourism choke sustainability? Tourism focal point 14 (2), 131. Middleton, V. T. C. and Hawkins, R. (1993) virtual(a) environmental policies in travel and tourism Part 1 The hotel sector. lead and Tourism analyst 6, 6376. Middleton, V. T. C. and Hawkins, R. (1994) pragmatic environmental policies in travel and tourism Part 2 Airlines, tour operators and destinations. strike and Tourism psychoanalyst 1, 8397. Murphy, P. E. (1994) Tourism and sustainable development. In W. Theobald (ed. ) Global Tourism the Next Decade. Oxford Butterworth-Heinemann. Nash, D. (1992) epilog A research agenda on the variabil ity of tourism. In V. L. Smith and W. R. Eadington (eds) Tourism alternatives Potentials and Problems in the Development of Tourism.Philadelphia University of Pennslyvania Press and the International Academy for the see of Tourism. Pearce, D. G. (1992) Alternative tourism concepts, classifications, and questions. In V. L. Smith and W. R. Eadington (eds) Tourism Alternatives Potentials and Problems in the Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 March 2013 A Framework of Approaches to Sustainable Tourism 233 Development of Tourism. Philadelphia University of Pennslyvania Press and the International Academy for the record of Tourism. Przeclawski, K. (1993) Tourism as the subject of interdisciplinary research. In D.G. Pearce and R. W. Butler (eds) Tourism research Critiques and Challenges. London Routledge and the International Academy for the Study of Tourism. Richter, L. K. (1987) The search for appropriate tourism. Tourism amusement Research 12 (2), 57. Tourism Concern (1992) b eyond the Green Horizon. London Tourism Concern and World Wide Fund for Nature. Travis, A. S. (1988) Alternative tourism. Naturopa 59, 257. Valentine, P. S. (1993) Ecotourism and reputation conservation. Tourism Management 14 (2), 10715. Van Praag, H. J. (1992) Industrial leading A practical example in the hotel industry.Tourism and the Environment Challenges and Choices for the 90s, November, 6266. West Country Tourist Board (1993) Green Audit Kit. Exeter WCTB. Wheeller, B. (1990) Is sustainable tourism appropriate? In F. Howie (ed. ) The Proceedings of the Sustainable Tourism Development Conference. Edinburgh, Queen Margaret College, November. Wheeller, B. (199la) Is industrial tourism appropriate? Tourism and hospitality Management completed Disciplines or ex Year Wonders? Guildford University of Surrey. Wheeller, B. (199lb) Tourisms roiling times accountable tourism is not the answer.Tourism Management 12 (2), 916. Wight, P. (1995) Sustainable ecotourism Balancing economi c, environmental and social goals at bottom an ethical framework. Tourism Recreation Research 20 (1), 513. World Commission on Environment and Development (1987) Our earthy Future. Oxford Oxford University Press. World Tourism ecesis (1989) Seminar on Alternative Tourism Introductory Report. capital of Spain WTO. World Tourism Organisation (1993) Seminar on the evolution of tourist markets for Europe and forward motion policies. WTO news program 3. World Tourism Organisation (1995a) Yearbook of Tourism Statistics (47th edn).Madrid WTO. World Tourism Organisation (1995b) WTO News 6. World Travel and Tourism Environment Research nitty-gritty (1992) World Travel and Tourism Environment canvas Travel and Tourism Environment and Development. capital of Belgium WTTERC. World Travel and Tourism Environment Research Centre (1993) World Travel and Tourism Environment analyze 1993 Environment and Development. capital of Belgium WTTERC. World Travel and Tourism Enviromnent Research Cent re (1994) World Travel and Tourism Environment Review 1994 Environment and Development. Brussels WTTERC. Downloaded by 113. 210. 1. 106 at 0728 22 March 2013